Archived Benington Parish Council Meeting Minutes & Reports        


Benington Parish Council Meeting
12 November 2008, 8.00 pm
Benington School

 Minutes

Present:                      H E L Jones (Chair)                Apologies:   J Presland
                                   R H Bott                                                S Mackey
                                   K Grundy                                                                   
                                   A V Robinson
                                   

In attendance:            P C Harrison (Clerk)  9 members of the public approx.

32.     Minutes

The minutes of the Parish Council Meeting held on10 September, 2008 were accepted as an accurate record and signed by the Chairman.

It was agreed that in future a review of actions should be listed on the agenda, under minutes of the last meeting, to ensure continuity.

33.     Declaration of Interests :    None

34.     Roads

The Chairman reported on the recent meeting with Highways.  Burns Green was of particular concern due to the number of pot holes in that area.  At the present time Highways do not have the funds available, unless there is a priority due to health and safety reasons, to cover general road repairs. Cost is prohibitive, as the road being worked on would have to be closed and traffic lights erected. 

The Parish Council were informed of pot holes at the entrance to Three Stiles.  The Clerk confirmed that these have been reported and would be followed up.

35.     Planning

35.1    A Planning application for Lingfields, Whempstead Road was received.  The Chairman stated that this would be circulated to each Councillor for reading.

35.2     Decisions

App No: 3/08/1301FP

Cuttings, Whempstead Road, Benington SG2 7DH
Demolition of single garage and construction of detached double garage with study above. 
East Herts Council permission refused.

App No: 3/08/1509/FP

Edelweiss, 10 Hebing End, Benington SG2 7DD
Fully glazed rear conservatory.
East Herts Council permission granted.

36.1     Playground

The Clerk circulated the annual playground inspection report, the only item in need of attention is the spring train, which has a loose foot and also the paint is flaking.  The report was passed to Cllr. Robinson for action.

37.     School

It was reported that Foundation and Class 1 are full to capacity.  A diocesan inspection was carried out on 6 October to assess the Christian character of the school. The Church of England graded the school as outstanding.

The application for the portable building at the back of the school, currently the pre-school, to become a permanent structure has now been sent to planning.  Grants are needed for a new classroom for the pre-school. Cllr. Grundy stated that the pre-school is an important aspect of the school with regard to keeping numbers high, and therefore ensuring finance from Hertfordshire County Council.

38.     Finance

38.1      Expenditure 

Approval was given for the following accounts:     


Date

To Whom Paid

Details

Total

30.09.08

Dragon Print & Design

Printing of Parish Plan

£3,178.00

04.10.08

Frank Cooper & Son

Grass Cutting

£    98.70

27.10.08

East Herts Council

Playground Inspection

£    56.39

30.10.08

C.D.A.

Subscription

£    30.00

31.10.08

BDO Stoy Haywards

Auditing Annual Return

£  193.88

01.11.08

Frank Cooper & Son

Grass Cutting

£    98.70

12.11.08

Herts County Council

Maintenance - Street Lights

£  249.06

12.11.08

Herts County Council

Energy – Street Lights

£  175.91

 

         

 

 

 

 

38.2     Accounts

Benington Parish Council Accounts for the 2nd Quarter of 2008/2009 attached.

38.3     Audit for the year ended 31 March, 2008

A copy of the Audited Annual Return for the year ended 31 March, 2008 was received and noted.
Issues arising:  Comparatives Restated. No further action needed.

The Chairman announced that the accounts were now open for inspection by appointment with the Clerk.

39.     Any other business

The question of Benington having a mobile post office was raised.  The Clerk is awaiting a reply from the Post Office Consultation Team on this subject.  The Clerk also referred to a letter received from the Post Office Consultation Team, which stated that the Benington Post Office was closed because it was underused.  A discussion ensued as to whether it would be possible or feasible for a hosted post office to be available in the village.  It was resolved that this was not feasible as pensions could not be received from a hosted post office. The Clerk to write to Barbara Follett MP for her support regarding a mobile post office.

The overgrown village pond to be inspected by the Council during the next few days.

Cllr. Bott has been approached regarding the provision of a BMX ramp on the recreation ground.  Whilst Cllr. Bott, whose family own the piece of land in question, is happy for this to go ahead the question of insurance and liability was raised if an accident should occur.  The Clerk to contact the Parish Council’s insurance company on this matter, and Cllr. Bott to provide a map specifying the area concerned. It was also agreed that information should be sought from the insurance policy covering the Recreation Club and Ground.

It was reported that tiles were missing from the roof of one of the wooden bus shelters. The Chairman agreed to arrange for a repair to be carried out during the next few weeks.

Quotes have now been received for a new notice board to be installed next to the wooden bus shelter at the bottom of Stoopers Hill.  This notice board will be supported on posts with lockable double glass doors taking eight sheets of A4 paper.  Page & Watts have come in with the lowest quote of approx., £300.00. Other quotes ranged from £700.00 to £1,000.00.  It was resolved to pursue the quote from Page & Watts.

The Chairman also suggested that a new notice board be placed on the Methodist Chapel to replace the old one.  A more suitable place for this notice board would be on posts near the post box outside the Lordship Arms.  No definite decision was reached.

The East Herts Planning Committee has re-scheduled the date for the wind farm application.  The new unconfirmed date is 14 January, 2009.

The Parochial Church Council is in the process of purchasing the organ in St Peter’s Church which is on loan from the diocese. The Parish Council is considering the possibility of making a donation towards the new organ, and a letter has been sent to Nigel Watling, Secretary of the PCC to this effect.  The Chairman invited Revd Norman Plumb to give details of this purchase.  Revd Plumb explained that the new organ would cost £9,000 as it stands, but will need work done to put it in good condition.  The cost of repairs would be in the region of £1,000 to £2,000, but when in good order would be worth twice as much so therefore a good investment.  The Chairman asked if other avenues had been explored, and a discussion ensued on the possibility of purchasing a new electronic organ.  The donation from the Parish Council would not need to be made until June 2009, therefore it was resolved to defer a decision until next year by which time an agreed amount could be allocated in the budget.

40.     Date of next meeting:

The next meeting will be on Wednesday, 14 January, 2009 at 8.00 pm in the school.

41.     Public Participation

Parishioners asked that Highways be informed of the following:

Street light out on the bus stop at Church Green.

Leaves on the path from Benington School to the Duck Pond making the pavement very slippery and dangerous.

The Clerk stated that the above items had been reported, but would follow up.

Concern was expressed regarding the overgrown hedge belonging to The Old Rectory, 2 Walkern Road.  The owner to be contacted about this problem.

Revd Plumb informed the Council that Jenny Cobb, Parish Hall Committee, may have the possibility of a grant for the renovations to the Village Hall from Grass Roots Funding.  The Parish Hall is owned by the Church of England, therefore it is not possible for the Parish Hall Committee to apply for the grant as overall turnover needs to be less than £25,000 to be eligible.  It was suggested that application could be made through one of the clubs that use the hall, such as the Badminton Club or alternatively the Parish Council could apply on behalf of the Parish Hall.  The Chairman to speak to Jenny Cobb on this matter.

The Chairman closed the meeting at 8.55 pm.

   

top of page

 

Benington Parish Council Meeting
10 September 2008, 8.00 pm
Benington School

 Minutes

Present:                      H E L Jones (Chair)                Apologies:   Jan Presland
                                    R H Bott
                                    K Grundy                               
                                    A V Robinson
                                    S Mackey                   
                                   

In attendance:            P C Harrison (Clerk) 16 members of the public approx.
________________________________________________________________________

20.     Chairman’s Report

The Chairman welcomed everybody to the meeting and gave a brief account of the stakeholder briefing meeting held by East Herts Council on 1st September, 2008 for the proposed wind farm application.  A decision on this planning application by East Herts Council will be made by 19 November, 2008.

The Chairman also informed the meeting that quotes were being received for a new notice board to be installed near the bus shelter at the bottom of Stoopers Hill.

 21.    Minutes

The minutes of the Parish Council Meeting held on 9 July, 2008 were accepted as an accurate record and signed by the Chairman.

22.     Matters Arising

Cllr. Shelagh Mackey raised the question of a mobile post office for the village.  The clerk has not yet received a reply to the Parish Council’s letter requesting the option of a post office in a new village shop. When this option has been formally turned down the clerk will write regarding the option of a mobile post office.

23.     Declaration of Interests :        None

24.     Roads

The Parish Council to organise a meeting with Highways to discuss the poor condition of the roads in Benington, particularly Whempstead Road and Burns Green.

25.     Planning

25.1   Decisions


LPA Ref: 3/98/1065/FP/HS
LPA Ref: 3/08/1066/LB/HS

7 Church Green, Benington SG2 7LH.
Rear extension – part two storey, and part single- storey.  General Building and Listed Building.
East Herts Council permission granted.
East Herts Council listed building permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/1190/LB/JS

5 Church Green, Benington SG2 7LH
Two storey side extension with dormer window  to rear elevation providing a larger kitchen and new bedroom.
BPC majority decision objecting to planning permission.
East Herts Council permission granted subject to conditions.  

LPA Ref: 3/08/1072FP/HS

20 Hebing End, Benington, Herts SG2 7DD
Two storey side and rear extensions to create residential annexe with single storey front and rear lean-to extensions.
BPC majority decision objecting to planning permission.
East Herts Council permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/1289/FP/SD

Elstow House, Whempstead Road, Benington, SG2 7DE. 
Single storey side extension, change
of rear window to double doors at ground and first floor level with Juliet balcony.
BPC no objection to planning permission.
East Herts Council permission granted.

25.2 The following applications were discussed at the meeting:

LPA Ref: 3/08/1490/FP/JS

Lingfields, Whempstead Road, Benington, SG2 7BX.
Two storey and single storey side and rear
extensions with rear pergola.
BPC no objection to planning permission.

LPA Ref: 3/08/1288/FP/MC

55 Town Lane, Benington, SG2 7LB
Erection of 6kw wind turbine on a 9m tower in rear garden.
BPC object to planning permission as this turbine will be visually intrusive to neighbouring properties, and there will possibly be a noise
problem.         

26.     Recreational Facilities

Stevenage Borough Girls’ Football Team are now playing at Benington.  On the question of funding, the Recreation Club are putting in a bid to the Football Foundation. The Chairman suggested that Cllr. Mackey telephone Giles Scrivener, District Councillor, who may be able to help with funding.

Giles Scrivener will be donating £250.00 to the Youth Club on behalf of East Herts District Council.  This will be given at a presentation evening with Jan Presland and some of the Youth Club in attendance.

Concern was expressed over the amount of litter left on the recreation field after matches.  It was decided to request that the football teams who use the field take their rubbish away with them after matches.  It was also agreed to look into the possibility of having a proper lockable bin on the recreation ground.

26.1     Playground:        Nothing to report.

27.     School

The formal report from Ofsted is excellent.  The maximum score of outstanding has been received in all sections.  Cllr. Ken Grundy paid tribute to Gill Hollingsworth, former head teacher, for all her work.  Mrs J Munn, Acting Head has one more course to complete before she formally takes over as Head Teacher.

28.     Finance

28.1    Expenditure
           
The Parish Council receive an annual grant for litter picking in the parish, and on this basis have arranged for the litter bins in the village to be emptied each week.  A new bin is also to be provided by East Herts Council near to the Lordship Arms Public House.

Approval was given for the following accounts:     


Date

To Whom Paid

Details

Total

05.08.08

Herts County Council

Street Lighting Energy

£175.91

05.08.08

Herts County Council

Street Lighting Maintenance

£249.06

11.08.08

Frank Cooper & Son

Grass Cutting

£148.05

18.08.08

St Peter’s Church

Upkeep of churchyard grant

£500.00

10.09.08

Fred Burnell

Pest Control – Moles

£188.00

10.09.08

Frank Cooper & Son

Grass Cutting

£49.35

 

         

 

 

 

28.2   Accounts

Benington Parish Council Accounts for the 1st Quarter of 2008/2009 attached.

29.     Any other business

Cllr. Richard Bott reported that the blocked gulley in High Elms Lane has not yet been repaired by Highways.  The Clerk to add this to the list of road problems to be discussed at the forthcoming meeting with Highways.

The Chairman stated that he had received a complaint about the overgrown perimeter of the village pond.  The Parish Council agreed to have a look at the pond to see what needed to be done.

The Parish Council has also received a complaint about the overflowing main sewer, adjacent to 90 Town Lane, at the bottom of Stoopers Hill. It was reported that this happens approximately twice a year, particularly when there is a heavy downpour.  The Clerk to contact Thames Water Authority regarding this problem. 

Flooding was also reported, due to a leaking stopcock, outside 96 Town Lane. The Clerk to inform Three Valleys Water.

The Parish Council has received copies of correspondence regarding a situation that has arisen concerning No 1 Oak Tree Close, Benington.  Cllr. Richard Bott explained the background to the situation in Oak Tree Close, and emphasised the importance of these houses to the village. Also, the fact that they were built as affordable houses to be made available to Benington people.  The Parish Council agreed to write to Sanctuary Housing  to ensure that the situation that has arisen with No 1 Oak Tree Close does not happen again, copies to be sent to East Herts Council, Barbara Follett MP and the local press.

30.     Date of next meeting:

The next meeting will be on Wednesday, 12 November at 8.00 pm in the school.

31.     Public Participation

Mr Ken Pomfret reminded the Council of a motion that had been proposed by Mr Ken Crofton at the extraordinary meeting on 25 June, for the removal of Cllr Richard Bott from the Parish Council.  The Chairman stated that he had received a reply from East Herts Council, Democratic Services to the effect that Richard Bott, as an elected Parish Councillor, cannot be removed for the reasons proposed.  The Chairman also confirmed that the Parish Council would not ask Richard Bott to resign, as he is a very useful member of the Parish Council.

Concern was expressed by a parishioner of the situation in Oak Tree Close. The Parish Council was asked to look into the archives, and the Parish Council Minutes, to see if there is any paperwork, or a record of the fact that these houses were built specifically for Benington people.  It was also suggested that East Herts Planning would have a record of Oak Tree Close, and the conditions under which they were built.

Parishioners asked that Highways be informed of the following problems:

Kerb dropped 3” in the car park at the bottom of 3 Stiles.

Pot holes in Blacksmiths Hill.

Pot holes outside ‘The Old House’, opposite 150 Town Lane.

Pot holes in Burns Green.

A question was raised reference the possibility of weight restrictions throughout the village.  The Chairman thought that this would not be possible because of Ernest Doe, Alchemy and farming vehicles that need access through the village.

Concern was expressed regarding the cars parked by the high grass bank in the centre of the village, especially vans, as they obstruct the view of oncoming traffic.  The Chairman suggested that the parishioner speak to the owners of the vans to see if it would be possible for them to move their vehicles further along the road so as not to obstruct the view.

The Chairman closed the meeting at 9.00 pm.

 

 

top of page

 
9 July 2008, 8.00 pm
Benington School

Minutes

Present: H E L Jones (Chair), A V Robinson, S Mackey

Apologies: R H Bott, K Grundy, J Presland

In attendance: P C Harrison (Clerk) 12 members of the public approx.

________________________________________________________________________

1. Minutes

The minutes of the Annual Parish Meeting and the previous Parish Council Meeting held on 14 May, 2008 were accepted as an accurate record and signed by the Chairman.

The minutes of the extraordinary meeting held on 25 June, 2008 were accepted as an accurate record and signed by the Chairman.

2. Declaration of Interests : None

3. Roads

Hertfordshire Highways to be informed of the following:

• Pot Holes 6” dia. outside nos. 29 to 41 Town Lane, south side.
• Pot Hole just past Willow Farm, Whempstead Road on the
right hand side going towards Hertford.

4. Footway – Town Lane

It was reported that the tarmac surface is cracking on the footpath outside nos. 29 to 55 Town Lane. Also, the hedging is hanging over the path making it difficult for people to walk along. Circle Anglia and Highways to be informed of this matter.

The badly damaged pavement on Stoopers Hill, reported three weeks ago and again today 09.07.08, is still in a dangerous condition. An email has been received from Raj Goutam, Hertfordshire Highways, stating that this work is programmed for early autumn.

5. Planning

5.1 Decisions

LPA Ref: 3/08/0796/FP 156 Town Lane, Benington SG2 7BT. New double garage and store to replace existing double garage.
East Herts Council permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0387/FP 7 Town Lane, Benington, SG2 7LA. Extension to the rear of no 7 & proposed new building replacing dilapidated timber building.
East Herts Council permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0553/LB 7 Town Lane, Benington, SG2 7LA. Extension to the rear of no 7 & proposed new building replacing dilapidated timber building.
East Herts Council listed building permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0531/FP/MC Village Hall, Walkern Road, Benington, SG2 7LN. Demolition of timber annex and construction of extension.
East Herts Council permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0532/LC Village Hall, Walkern Road, Benington, SG2 7LN Demolition of timber annex and construction of extension.
East Herts Council Conservation Area permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0600/FP The Croft, 2 Town Lane, Benington SG2 7LA. Erection of timber frame and clad building incorporating a stable and storage area.
East Herts Council permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0762/LB Benington Park, Benington SG2 7BU.
Construction of new double doors at raised ground floor level on the SE side of the house opening onto a new terrace.
East Herts Council listed building permission granted.

5.2 Applications dealt with during the preceding month, but not discussed at the Parish Council Meeting.

LPA Ref: 3/98/1065/FP/HS
LPA Ref: 3/08/1066/LB/HS 7 Church Green, Benington SG2 7LH
Rear extension – part two storey, and part single-storey. General Building and Listed Building.
BPC no objection.

6. Recreational Facilities

The Stevenage Borough Girls Football Team have started an after school football club which is proving to be very popular, and will help to raise funds for the new pavilion.

6.2 Playground

The grass has now been cut in the playground area. The Chairman stated that East Herts Council are doing less grass cutting in the village, and the Parish Council would need to increase the precept next year to pay for grass cutting in the village.

7. School

Ofsted have been to inspect the school, but have not yet released their report. Cllr Shelagh Mackey said that she had heard through the Governors and the feedback system that the report would be good. The new Headmistress, Mrs J Munn has now taken over from Mrs G Hollingsworth.

8. Finance

8.1 Expenditure

An invoice from Bridletree (1984) for £275.00 was approved for payment. The Chairman explained that this account was for a structural engineer plus disbursements for the proposed pavilion at Benington Recreation Ground. The Parish Council has set aside £3000.00 per year to help with the pavilion.

Approval was also given for the following accounts:

Date To Whom Paid Details

Total

27.06.08 St Peter’s Church Hire of Parish Hall £80.00
30.06.08 Frank Cooper & Son Grass Cutting £98.70

9. Any other business

The Chairman drew attention to a letter received from Hertfordshire County Council reference Post Office Closures in Hertfordshire. Negotiations are still ongoing to try and re-open a village shop, and it would benefit the village to have the option of a Post Office. The Chairman agreed to write to Hertfordshire County Council with regard to a scheme where District Councils are buying local Post Offices. Benington’s nearest Post Offices are Dane End, Walkern and Watton-at-Stone. Residents wishing to write to the Post Office about the proposed Benington closure will find details on the village notice boards.

The Clerk was asked to look into a possible government ruling that all urban and rural areas should have a Post Office within one mile.

10. Date of next meeting:

The next meeting will be on Wednesday, 10 September at 8.00 pm in the school.


11. Public Participation

The Chairman invited questions from the floor.

It was suggested from the floor that a mobile post office could be an option. The Clerk to look into this suggestion.

A question was asked about whether or not a village shop would be re-opened and if so where. The Chairman explained the various options that had been put forward, although nothing has been decided.

Mr Tony Nolan expressed concern about the state of the roads in Benington. Mr Nolan was particularly concerned about the area of road outside his own house on the Whempstead Road. This area of road is uneven due to the repair of many small pot holes, and the noise in the early hours of the morning of lorries going over this area is proving to be a nuisance. A resident of Burns Green reported the appearance of large pot holes at the end of Burns Green.

It was reported that there is no drain cover outside no. 88 Town Lane making it positively dangerous for motorists.

In view of the many complaints about the state of the roads, the Chairman asked the Clerk to arrange a meeting with Highways, on site, to try and resolve these problems.

The Chairman closed the meeting at 8.35 pm.

 

top of page

 

Extraordinary Meeting
25 June 2008, 8.00 pm
Benington School

 Minutes

Present:                      H E L Jones (Chair)                Apologies:   R H Bott
                                   K W Grundy                                             
                                   J R Presland
                                   A V Robinson
                                   S Mackey

In attendance:            P C Harrison (Clerk)    60 members of the public approx.
________________________________________________________________________

The Chairman welcomed everybody to the meeting.

1.    Apologies were received from the Chair for Richard Bott, due to a personal and prejudicial interest.

2.    Results of the Wind Farm Questionnaire

The Chairman announced the results of the Benington Wind Farm Questionnaire:-

Number of people on electoral roll                           680

Number of people completing questionnaire              444      (66%)

Number in favour of turbines                                     80      (18%)

Number against turbines                                         352      (80%)

Number who don’t know                                          12      (2%)

3.         The Chairman confirmed that the Parish Council, in accordance with the results of the questionnaire, would strongly oppose the wind farm planning application.  The Chairman asked for suggestions from the floor to reinforce the Council’s objection to the wind farm.

3.1  Points raised from the floor

(a)  The Council was asked if they knew the results of the anemometer readings, and whether or not they showed the turbines to be a viable proposition. The Council responded that they had no knowledge of the anemometer readings.

(b)  It was reported that during the 1970s a scheme to run pylons across the Beane Valley was opposed by Harry Bott.  The focus of the argument against pylons was on the beauty of the landscape.  The question was raised as to whether or not there is documentation relating to why this scheme was refused.

(c)  It was suggested from the floor that the Stop Benington Wind Farm committee and the Parish Council, work together on the response to East Herts Council to oppose the wind farm application.  The Chairman reported that it had been proposed, representatives from the Parish Councils of Benington, Aston, Watton at Stone and Datchworth meet to discuss various points of view.  The Chairman stated that Watton at Stone are holding a Special Meeting on 14th July with reference to the wind farm. Aston have sent out a questionnaire to be completed by 29th June, and are holding a meeting on Monday, 30 June.   

(d) Carol Pomfret (co-compiler of the Parish Plan), reported that information gathered for the Parish Plan showed a very strong view for Benington to remain as it is, a rural village. Carol to provide the Council with relevant points from the Plan.

(e)  The Parish Council was asked if an expert in examining wind farm applications would be involved in looking at the application.  The Chairman responded that he and the other Councillors were all reading the application. Julian Godlee from the Stop Benington Wind Farm committee stated that he had been looking at the application very carefully, along with an expert used to looking at wind farm applications.

(f)   Concern was raised regarding the large vehicles that will be used to transport the wind turbines.  The Chairman explained the route the vehicles would take, and a discussion ensued on the disruption that would be caused during the construction process.  The road safety aspect of transportation along narrow lanes was also emphasized.

(g)  Points were made reference the building of a sub-station to generate electricity.

(h)  It was reported that the actual type of turbine to be used, had not yet been established.

(i)  Questions were raised on the health impact of the wind farm, particularly on young babies and the elderly.

(j)  Concern was expressed with reference to the distance of family housing from the turbines.  Some residents were only 600 meters from the proposed site of the turbines.

(k)  It was reported that an estimated 243 houses, would no longer be able to receive terrestrial TV through a conventional aerial.

(l)  MOD security issues were raised.  There had been no objections from the CAA with reference to radar.

(m)       The question of noise from the wind turbines was discussed.  Keith Luetchford  reported that a public environment law company in Cambridge, who deal with many wind farms, have confirmed that it is quite common to get a noise problem.  Keith agreed to write to the Parish Council with details of the company in Cambridge, and information on the noise problem.

4. Letters to East Herts Council

The Chairman reminded the meeting that letters to East Herts Council regarding the wind farm application should be sent before 3 July 2008.  However, the Chairman has received verbal notification by East Herts Council that letters received before 29 August 2008 will be considered.  The Chairman also reminded residents to not only write or email the Parish Council, but ensure their letters are sent to East Herts Planning Department.   A discussion ensued reference the content of an objection letter, and it was pointed out that the Stop Benington Wind Farm committee have circulated a leaflet containing access to information on ‘How to Write an Objection Letter’ on their website.

5.  Planning Application

The Chairman confirmed that the full planning application for the wind farm would be made available, if residents would like to have another opportunity to look at the contents.

6.  Datchworth Wind Farm Meeting

It was requested that the clerk look into the time and place of the Datchworth wind farm meeting, and pass on details to Peter Kingsnorth.

7. Noise Consultant

Cllr Shelagh Mackey asked if the Parish Council should consider employing a noise consultant to look into the problem of wind farm noise. The Chairman expressed concern as to whether it would be right for the Council to spend money on this matter. The Stop Benington Wind Farm committee to give the Parish Council an indication of cost.

8. Letter to R H Bott & Son

The Parish Council was asked to write to R H Bott & Son, requesting that they withdraw their wind farm application in view of the strength of feeling in the village against the application.  The Chairman agreed to write to R H Bott & Son.

9.  Vote of no confidence   

Ken Crofton, as a representative of the Stop Benington Wind Farm committee, proposed a vote of no confidence in Cllr Richard Bott.  Ken Crofton asked that Cllr Bott stand down from the Parish Council, as his involvement in the wind farm application meant that he was out of step with the village. A debate ensued regarding Cllr Bott’s position on the Parish Council.

A proposal was put forward from the floor of the meeting that Cllr Richard Bott resign from the Parish Council.  This was not seconded.  A show of hands, which was not counted, showed the majority of the floor in favour of Cllr Bott’s permanent removal from the Parish Council.  The Chairman agreed to write to Cllr Bott, outlining the feelings of the meeting.
           
The legalities of this situation were then brought into question.  The Chairman stated that he would need to check with Democratic Services at E.H.D.C. regarding the Parish Council’s legal position concerning this proposal, and nothing more would be done until clarification is received.

10.  Future Matters    

Concern was expressed regarding other landowners in the surrounding area erecting wind farms, if the Benington wind farm goes ahead.  Concern over the appeal process, if R H Bott & Son decided to appeal, was also expressed. The Chairman stated that a discussion on the appeal process would take place in a future meeting, should this matter arise.

The Chairman closed the meeting at 9.10 pm

 

 

top of page

 

14 May, 2008, 8.00 pm
Benington School

Minutes

Present:                      H E L Jones (Chair)                Apologies:   None
                                    R H Bott
                                    K W Grundy                                             
                                    J R Presland
                                    A V Robinson
                                    S Mackey

In attendance:            P C Harrison (Clerk)    25 members of the public approx.
________________________________________________________________________

1.       Minutes

The minutes of the meeting held on 05 March, 2008 were accepted as an accurate record and signed by the Chairman.

2.       Declaration of Interests :        None

3.       Roads

Circle Anglia to be informed of the following.

  • Pot holes in Blacksmiths Hill.
  • Pot holes along the road to garages in 3 Stiles.
  • Drain cover missing near the garages in 3 Stiles.

Hertfordshire Highways to be informed of the following:

  • Reported road sinking outside Finches Farm still not repaired.
  • Pot holes outside No. 90 have been repaired, but the road is

still very uneven and patchy.

4.       Planning

4.1     Decisions

The Certificate of Lawful Use or Development reference: Land at Brandsmead,
1 Whempstead Road, Benington, Herts. SG2 7BX.  East Herts Council – Certificate issued.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0239/FP/CT

Hillside Cottage, 79 Town Lane, Benington,
Herts SG2 7BT. Installation of solar panels Retrospective.
East Herts Council permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0104/FP/JS

63 & 65 Town Lane, Benington, Herts.
Construction of a cross-over and a bridge to
facilitate off-road parking. East Herts Council
permission refused.

LPA Ref: 3/07/2515/ON

Renewal of outline planning permission for
5 detached houses, Alchemist Works Site,
Whempstead Road, Benington, SG2 7BX. East Herts Council permission granted.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0429/FP/JS

75A Town Lane, Benington, SG2 7BT. Ground
floor rear kitchen and first bedroom extension.
East Herts Council permission granted.

4.3       Applications dealt with during the preceding month, but not discussed at the Parish Council Meeting.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0429/FP/JS

75A Town Lane, Benington, SG2 7BT. Ground floor rear kitchen and first bedroom extension.
BPC majority decision objecting to planning permission. 

LPA Ref: 3/08/0387/FP/SD

7 Town Lane, Benington, SG2 7LA. Extension to the rear of no 7 & proposed new building replacing dilapidated timber building. 
BPC majority  decision objecting to planning permission.

LPA Ref: 3/08/0531/FP/MC

Village Hall, Walkern Road, Benington, SG2 7LN
Demolition of timber annex and construction of extension.
BPC no objection.

 

 

5.       Recreational Facilities

5.1       Brick Building

Cllr Jan Presland asked about progress of work on the brick building.  Cllr Richard
Bott replied that he should be able to make a start on the work this month.

5.2       Pavilion

Councillors Jan Presland and Shelagh Mackey are meeting on 15 May, 2008 to discuss the pavilion.  It was reported that the football pitches will be used by one club only Stevenage Borough Girls Football Team.  This team have offered to help complete a grant form to be sent to the Football Association.  Stevenage Borough Girls have also agreed to a proviso that if there is a  Benington Football Team in the future, they will also be able to use the ground.

Three quotes have now been received for the re-building of the new pavilion.

It was reported that the portacabin has been broken into again, and somebody has offered to repair it.

5.3       Playground:   Nothing to report.

6.       School

The Headmistress, Mrs G Hollingsworth is retiring at the end of the summer term. Mrs J Munn will takeover as Acting Head.

7.       Finance

7.1        Expenditure

Approval was given for the following accounts:     


Date

To Whom Paid

Details

Total

14.05.08

St Peter’s Church

Upkeep of Churchyard and
Installation of tap.

£2,200.00

14.05.08

Frank Cooper & Son

Grass Cutting

£     49.35

14.05.08

McCash and Hay

Internal Audit

£   129.25

 

         

 

 

7.2     Annual Return

The annual return for the year ended 31 March, 2008 was approved by the council and signed at the meeting.

8.       Any other business

It was brought to the Parish Council’s attention that grass cuttings in 3 Stiles were left in the road.  It was thought that this was the responsibility of Highways, therefore the clerk  to write to Highways about this matter.

It was reported that safety fencing has been erected around the site for the new bungalows in Three Stiles.

A letter has been received from South Anglia Housing, in reply to a letter from the Parish Council regarding high rental charges for garages in Blacksmiths Hill and Three Stiles. South Anglia has agreed to review these charges, but unfortunately any changes or decisions will not come into effect until April 2009.  Mr R White, who has a garage in Blacksmiths Hill, and who has campaigned against these high rental charges, has written to South Anglia stating his dissatisfaction with this decision.  The Parish Council proposed to wait and see Mr White’s reply from South Anglia before taking further action. Cllr Presland  reported that the garages in Three Stiles were in a bad state of repair.  

The problem of drainage in Blacksmiths Hill and Three Stiles was raised. It was agreed that the Clerk should write to South Anglia, requesting a representative meet with Cllr Presland and Cllr Bott on site to discuss this situation.  The Clerk was asked to send a copy of all correspondence relating to this problem to Mrs K Jackson, Three Stiles.

The Chairman summarised the contents of a letter received on 30 April, 2008 from Three Valleys Water, regarding its Draft Water Resources Management Plan (2010-2035), which sets out how the Company will balance the supply of and demand for water over the next 25 years.   The Chairman read out the date, time and place of a number of regional presentations should a representative of the Parish Council wish to attend.  After a brief discussion, it was suggested that the letter should be copied to the Beane Valley Restoration Association with a view to one of their representatives attending a presentation.

The East Herts Rural Parish Conference is due to take place on Thursday, 29 May 2008.  The Chairman stated that he would attend, and asked if any other Councillors were able to attend the Conference. Councillors Grundy and Robinson expressed a wish to attend, time and diary commitments permitting.

The Chairman confirmed that the application for the wind farm will be going in very shortly.  The Parish Council have decided, once it is in, to circulate a questionnaire around the village.  All residents over the age of 18 are eligible to complete this questionnaire.  The Village Hall will be opened from 9 am to 12 noon on a Sunday, exact date to be arranged, for residents to deliver their completed questionnaire for counting.  The Parish Council will hold a meeting on the following Wednesday to discuss the result.  The Chairman reiterated that the Parish Council would like the residents of Benington to decide on this issue and the Parish Council would be guided by the results of the questionnaire.  It was agreed that transport would be arranged for any resident with a problem getting to the Village Hall on the Sunday in question. 

The Chairman thanked Pam Harrison, on behalf of the Parish Council, for her work on completion of her first year as Clerk.

Date of next meeting:            9 July, 2008 at 8.00 pm.

The Chairman closed the meeting at 8.15 pm.

 

top of page

 

Annual Meeting of Benington Parish Council
14 May, 2008,
7.30 pm
Benington School

 Minutes

Present:                      H E L Jones (Chair)                Apologies:   None
                                    R H Bott
                                    K W Grundy                                             
                                    J R Presland
                                    A V Robinson
                                    S Mackey

In attendance:            P C Harrison (Clerk)    25 members of the public approx.
________________________________________________________________________

1.  Election of Chairman and signing of Declaration of Acceptance of Office

Lloyd Jones asked for nominations for the election of Chairman.

Ken Grundy nominated Lloyd Jones.

Richard Bott and Mrs Jan Presland seconded the motion and all present were in favour.  Lloyd Jones was duly elected and signed the declaration of acceptance of office.

2.  Election of Vice-Chairman and signing of Declaration of Acceptance of Office
       
Ken Grundy nominated Mr Richard Bott for the election of Vice-Chairman.

Mrs Jan Presland seconded the motion and all present were in favour.  Richard Bott      was duly elected and signed the declaration of acceptance of office.

3.  To fix the amount of the Chairman’s allowance in pursuance of section 15(5) of        
     the Local Government Act 1972

The Chairman’s allowance was agreed at £50.00.

4.  To fix the dates and times of ordinary meetings of the Council for the ensuing
       year

It was agreed that the ordinary Parish Council meetings would be held on the 2nd
Wednesday, every other month, throughout the year.  Dates as follows:

            9 July, 2008                 10 September, 2008                12 November, 2008

           14 January, 2009          11 March, 2009                       13 May, 2009

       These dates may be subject to change.

5.  Appointment of Representatives to other Organisations

      Benington School

      Mr Ken Grundy
      Mrs Jan Presland
      Mrs Shelagh Mackey

      Recreation Committee

      Mrs Jan Presland
      Mrs Shelagh Mackey

6.  Any other business
 
      None.

      The meeting closed at 7.45 pm.

 

   
   
   

February 2005 Report

There has not been a Parish Council meeting this month; however, there are a few items of news worth reporting.

The following planning application has been received:
The Croft, Town Lane, Benington – Listed building consent for the conversion of existing stable block to form a single dwelling.

• The schedule of works for the rebuilding of the pavilion at the recreation ground will be with the insurance assessors by the end of this month when it is hoped they will guarantee the sum assured for the rebuilding costs. There may well be a public meeting to decide how to proceed with the rebuilding, for now is surely the time to alter, enlarge, or change the building to render it more useful for the whole community.

• The second Parish Plan meeting took place on 26 January, which again was well supported, and from this meeting Carole Pomfret was elected to chair the steering committee with Michael Spicer as vice chair and Richard Reedy as treasurer. Other members of the steering committee are:

Harry Bott, Ken Grundy, Alison Wood, Sylvia Reedy, William Hill, Roger Melbourne, Bob Morcom.

Carole and Michael have already had two meetings with Susan Clarke from the Rural Enterprise Project to move the plan forward.

• The Parish Council wrote to Watton Place Clinic asking various questions concerning Oak Tree Surgery. They, in their response, admit that they are a doctor short but wish to recruit a female doctor due to patient demand, but there is a national shortage of GPs. Their answers are printed below:

  1. As you know, we are now looking after five thousand patients which is considerably more than the national average. This means that we are extremely busy and may not always arrive at the surgery promptly.
  2. GP hours have now changed to enable us to have some time with our families – like the rest of the population and in line with dentists, lawyers, accountants and other professionals. Anyone needing to see a doctor will either be off work already because they are sick or for routine matters will have to take time off.
  3. People travel from Watton to Benington if there are vacant spaces at Benington as often Benington patients do not fill the appointment slots. In the past we have had to cancel nursing sessions at Benington because of poor uptake.
  4. Our records show that very few people change from Stevenage surgeries to Watton.
    (taken from letter dated 11 January 2005, signed by Dr David Haslam)

• Several people have asked to see the written results of the Benington Housing Needs Survey. To print it in this magazine would make it rather bulky, therefore, it will be posted on the village website at www.benington-herts.co.uk as well as being available to view at Vic Robinson’s house by appointment only.

• As was mentioned in Januarys report the East of England Area Plan has reared it ugly head. Ken Grundy, representing the Parish Council, attended a meeting on this subject which was addressed by Mike Carver, Leader of East Herts District Council. Ken’s report, ‘Planning an Emotive Subject’ follows this Parish Council report.

• Also in January’s report it was stated that the new bus shelter had received many favourable comments, this obviously spurred some mindless individual or individuals, to realise that there was obviously something that had not been vandalised: it has now! Words fail me on this totally inane act of vandalism and of course once it starts the rest of the mindless flock follow. The Parish Council will of course try to restore the shelter to its former glory but there are people who know who is responsible for this, examine your conscience.

Next Parish Council Meeting 9 March 2005, 8pm at the school

   

top of page

   
January 12 2005

• The following planning application has been received:
- The Croft, Town Lane, Benington – Erection of new agricultural building, storage hay and implements for maintenance of garden and field

• The year has started badly for the village with the fire at the pavilion, caused by an electrical fault, which has completely destroyed the building. The insurance assessors are due to inspect the building on 18 January.

• The football club and the youth club have lost their meeting place and moves are afoot to overcome theses problems. The youth club is moving to the Parish Hall and the Parish Council has donated £50 to them to replace vital equipment.

• The Parish Council has received a reply to its letter to Watton Place Clinic but it arrived too late for any comment to be made in this publication.

• The website for the village is up and running and can be found at www.benington-herts.co.uk

• The footpath from the Green to the school has been cut back by the Highways Partnership, so at least we know that they do exist!

• Last year the Parish Council gained planning permission to build a new bus shelter at the bottom of Stoopers Hill. It was intended to build a brick shelter with voluntary labour and donations etc. However, the number of so many favourable comments regarding the replacement shelter on the Green has prompted the Parish Council to place a replica one at the bottom of Stoopers Hill. This will not involve any increase in the precept and will serve passengers going to Stevenage.

• There is the second Parish Plan Meeting on 26 January at the Parish Hall at 8pm, when it is hoped that a chairperson, secretary and treasurer will be found. If you would like to volunteer for any of these posts please telephone me.

• There are various meetings in January and February when the leader of East Herts District Council will endeavour to explain the East of England Area Plan. Parish Councillors will be attending and reports will be made.

• The Parish Council is to pursue Stort Valley Housing Association with regards to vacant garage sites, the Rebecca bungalows opposite the shop and any other proposal it has for the village.

• The Parish Council is to strongly oppose the latest application for the proposed agricultural building with the grounds of The Croft.

• Finally if you see a missed call on your mobile phone beginning 0709 do not return the call unless you are certain who it is, otherwise it will cost you £50 per minute!

Thank you for so many people turning up to the last Parish Council meeting. It shows that people are interested in the village and makes the Parish Council’s work seem all the more worthwhile.

Next meeting – 9 March 2005, 8pm at the school.

   
top of page

   

November 10 2004

• The following planning applications have been received:
- The Croft – change of use from stabling to dwelling, more detailed than original application
- Alchemy Metals – change of use from metal recycling site to residential

• Complaints have been received from residents about the use or lack of use of the surgery in Oak Tree Close and the hours it operates. The Parish Council has written to Watton Place Clinic pointing out these problems and invited the Practice to respond along with an indication for its future plans. No response has been received to date.

• The footpath from The Green to the school was also the subject of complaints and immediately after the last Parish Council meeting both householders whose gardens front the footpath, clearedtheir grass and overhanging hedges, etc., and a small parish working party cleared the leaves. On 9 December 2004 a meeting was held with Ed Fisher of the Highways partnership who has promised to cut back the encroaching soil to restore the path to its full width. He pointed out however, that the manhole covers in the bank could not be moved and therefore would protrude.

• On the subject of the above path, the Parish Council has received a letter from the owners of The Old Rectory complaining about car parking at school times, litter in the hedges along the path and generally making one or two very interesting suggestions. The letter will be passed on to the school governors.

• The Parish Council is in the process of setting up a website for Benington village. The set-up costs are very kindly being sponsored by Ernest Doe & Sons of Benington and the Parish Council would like to thank the company very much for its generosity. There will be more information about the website in the next issue of the Parish Magazine.

• The Parish Council now has an email address, beningtonparishcouncil@yahoo.co.uk.

• A very successful Benington Parish Plan Meeting was held on the 1 December 2004 at the Parish Hall where some 70 people attended. How to set up the Plan and how it works was explained by representatives of East Herts District Council and the Rural Enterprise Project. A general question and answers session followed and after the meeting refreshments were served by Friends of Benington School whom we are grateful to. Thirty people expressed their interest in becoming involved with the creation of the Plan and a meeting in January will be held for these people to take the project further. Thank you to all who attended and helped out – it all made for a worthwhile and interesting evening.

• Over the next few weeks the Parish Council will be conducting a survey to find out if residents between Stoopers Hill and the junction of Three Stiles would use a car park if it was provided.

Next Parish Council Meeting
Wednesday 12 January 2005, 8pm, at the school.

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 















Go back to Parish Council Page


top of page
   
         
Home | News | Community | Village Interest | Information | Services | Photographs | Contact
© 2005